How to Write a Critical Review of a Journal Article | Queen'sseasoned editor gives advice to get your work published in an international journal. with writing your paper and citing your sources using apa and other styles. for a full discussion of how to select an appropriate journal see knight and steinbach (2008). professional editing companies charge hefty fees, and it is simply not financially viable to have them conduct multiple rounds of editing on your article. while there are several types of research articles, such as short communications, review papers and so forth, these guidelines focus on preparing a full article (including a literature review), whether based on qualitative or quantitative methodology, from the perspective of the management, education, information sciences and social sciences disciplines.
The Article Review - Writing Help - Research Guides at Centralthe first is the revised manuscript highlighting all the modifications made following the recommendations received from the reviewers. acknowledgements i would like to thank professor heikki karjaluoto, jyväskylä university school of business and economics for providing valuable feedback on this article. to write the academic critique assignment--critique of academic journal article. selecting an appropriate publication outlet: a comprehensive model of journal selection criteria for researchers in a broad range of academic disciplines, international journal of doctoral studies. an essay, a critique uses a formal, academic writing style and has a clear structure, that is, an introduction, body and conclusion.
the standard of english can help manuscripts make it through to peer review. you start writing, it is important to have a thorough understanding of the work that will be critiqued. once you have read and re-read your manuscript carefully several times, received feedback from your colleagues, and identified a target journal, the next important step is to read the aims and scope of the journals in your target research area. for academic journals is a highly competitive activity, and it’s important to understand that there could be several reasons behind a rejection. the second is a letter listing the authors’ responses illustrating they have addressed all the concerns of the reviewers and editors.
in doing so, i highlight any sections of the manuscript that i would like reviewers to be absolutely clear on. writing the critical review requires that you read the selected article in detail and read other related articles so that, in the end, you can present an objective and educated evaluation. he has published in the elsevier journals computers in human behavior and telematics and informatics and other refereed journals such as the journal of financial services marketing, the international journal of e-business research and the international journal of electronic finance. this article, intended for doctoral students and other young scholars, i identify common pitfalls and offer helpful solutions to prepare more impactful papers. also ask colleagues about the most appropriate journal to submit my manuscript to; finding the right journal for your article can dramatically improve the chances of acceptance and ensure it reaches your target audience.