Product Selection---Witchcraft or Wisdom - IEEE Xplore Document the hypothesis received its most prominent exposition when adopted by the british egyptologist margaret murray, who presented her version of it in the witch-cult in western europe (1921), before further expounding it in books like the god of the witches (1931) and in her contribution to the encyclopædia britannica. all five incorporate at least one of the themes found in macbeth and are broad enough so that it will be easy to find textual support, yet narrow enough to provide a focused clear thesis statement. historians have viewed ginzburg's ideas as being related to murray's; hungarian historian gábor klaniczay stated that "ginzburg reformulated murray's often fantastic and very inadequately documented thesis about the reality of the witches' sabbath" and thus the publication of i benandanti in 1966 "reopened the debate about the possible interconnections between witchcraft beliefs and the survival of pagan fertility cults".
Salem Witch Trials: Argumentative Essay Topic Ideas since the 1960s, scholars like carlo ginzburg have argued that surviving elements of pre-christian religion in european folk culture influenced the early modern stereotypes of witchcraft, with scholars debating how this relates to the murrayite witch-cult hypothesis. the witch-cult hypothesis states that such stories are based upon a real-life pagan cult that revered a horned god. are researchers who claim that the witch trials in salem occurred not only because of puritan beliefs, but also due to economic reasons.